Monday, June 04, 2007

Protecting the Delicate Ears

When I write here or on other public forums, I almost never use explicit profanity. For instance: sh!t is a common alternative for me. The reason for this is not personal preference - I swear like a sailor. In fact, I am one of those people that forgets and swears in front of little kids. Instead, I avoid explicitly swearing because I am sympathetic to people whose work IT system flags obscene language. It is not fair to them to have their access blocked or worse, to get in trouble for navigating to websites with unexpected nasty language.

But that is very different from mainstream news organizations' style guides. Today I have come across a really annoying example from the WaPo:

A federal appeals court tossed out an indecency ruling against Rupert Murdoch's Fox television network today, sending a stern rebuke to the Federal Communications Commission and groups that seek tighter federal regulation of the airwaves.

In a 2-1 decision, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit in New York ruled that the FCC went too far in issuing a 2006 indecency decision against Fox for separate incidents in 2002 and 2003 when singer Cher and celebrity Nicole Richie, respectively, both uttered the f-word on live television.


The construct of "f-word" or its cousins like "the n-word" is akin to substituting "doody" for sh!t, akin to when people jump through hoops to avoid saying penis or, even worse, vagina. It is especially silly when a newspaper writes an article about the use of the word f$#k but does not even use the word.

I agree that some language is harsh or offensive and that caution should be the rule when using that language. But dispassionate news reporting does not and should not carry any connotation. I look forward to the day when an editor feels comfortable not acting like a ninny and treating readers like fragile creatures unable to withstand the pain of ugly words.

No comments:

Who links to me?