Ann Althouse is a person that irritates the hell out of me. As I outlined this post in my head, I tried to understand what it was specifically that irritated me and I came to the conclusion that it is a combination of ego, self-righteousness, spite and meanness. She also seems to think that her point of view is the only acceptable view and expresses contempt for dissenters. (For a good example of these traits summed up in one incident, see this story and her response about a libertarian conference and racism.) I usually do not read her blog unless someonee else links to it and I am curious to get the "full story" which is how I stumbled upon the referenced story.
But, today, trying to follow the libertarian story on her blog, I came across this post which I found stunning in its cruelty.
I had not realized it, but Andrew "The Naked Guy" Martinez - a one time student of UC Berkeley and nudity advocate - killed himself about a year ago. The New York Times Magazine wrote about it in a run down of 2006 notable deaths. Apparently he suffered from schitzophrenia and had, for quite some time, been very very ill.
[After his expulsion, h]e began to wander Berkeley pushing a shopping cart filled with rocks. He’d place the rocks at major intersections, trying to disrupt traffic, and he’d make piles of them all over the city so that, as he explained to his girlfriend at the time, “people would have weapons for when the revolution comes.” He seemed to seek out confrontations with the police, once luring them to the co-op where he lived and pelting them with compost. He was arrested on multiple occasions.
After a period, Martinez left Berkeley and moved back to Cupertino to live with his mother and stepfather. Although he no longer went naked in public, his erratic behavior continued, and schizophrenia was eventually diagnosed. He spent the next decade shuttling between jails and mental-health institutions.
I went to college with The Naked Guy and always admired his attitude though I found his cause silly. (I never saw him naked which I have always considered one of my "missed opportunities" in my life. Once I did see him in his tighty whities but that just is not the same.) Good for him and screw the school, probably sums up my thoughts at the time. I was also angered at the time at the way people really disliked him just because he was different. A guy walking around naked really seemed to freak people out. And rather than chuckle many were pretty viscious.
14 years later Althouse continues the visciousness. According to the NYT,
Until his death, Martinez’s family and friends did their best to keep his mental illness a secret. This was at his request. “Andrew did not want people to know about his illness,” his mother said, “because then they would think he was crazy the whole time.” In his moments of lucidity, there was one thing he desperately wanted to convey: “When he was the Naked Guy,” one friend said, “he was completely sane.”
To that, Althouse responds,
This is very sad, including the poignant way his mother and friend seem to think that if only he had been allowed to live amongst us in the nude, he would have kept it together.
The quotes from his mother and friend are the only two in the article not from him so clearly they convey something very important to The Naked Guy and his family - that his nudism was not a symptom of his disease but something he genuinely believed in. Is that true? I do not know but I am willing to take his family's word for it.
But it is not just his family. According the NYT piece, after he was expelled,
he wasn’t the same Naked Guy as before. Friends noticed that something was amiss: Martinez had become angry — angry about his expulsion, angry that the media had moved on to other stories, angry that no rich nudist had come forward to bankroll the lawsuit he wanted to file against the university. He started to talk of sinister forces, like the C.I.A., that he claimed were trying to thwart him.
Wikipedia lists among the causes of schitzophrenia, "Considerable evidence indicates that stressful life events cause or trigger schizophrenia." Stressful events like getting expelled from college? Stressful events like being ridiculed by just about everyone? Stressful events like being unable to be yourself?
But Althouse, like many people back at the time, apparently refuses to believe that someone who champions nudism could be sane. In her effort to belittle his cause by denying it any basis she goes his mother and friend. She cruelly attacks his them by heaping pity upon what she considers to be their delusions. It is most definitley
not sad that his friends and family believe him to have been sane when he was a student. Not only are they entitled to their beliefs, but they are the ones in the best position to know whether it is true or not. Shame on you Ms. Althouse. While the dead may not always deserve respect, the grieving definitely do.
Why are people so uncomfortable with nudity and non-conformity?
Rest in peace Naked Guy. I am going to go downstairs and have a drink in your honor and to thank you for bringing the Bezerkeley into my Berkeley experience.