Deny It Now!
A few weeks ago, there was an AP story about 6 Sunni worshippers being dragged out of a mosque in Iraq and burned alive which created an echo chamber controversy in the conservative blogs. Here's a quick recap:
A quick recap on this whole current attack on the AP: Malkin and her colleagues have been blasting the AP relentlessly over a story it ran in November recounting an episode in which six Sunni worshipers were said to have been drenched in kerosene and burned alive by Shiites. Malkin and a bunch of other wingnuts, along with U.S. and Iraqi officials, have questioned the veracity of the story. Even though the AP went back and re-reported out the story, finding new witnesses and issuing strong statements standing behind it, the righty bloggers have kept this bone in their teeth for weeks. Malkin and company are alleging that one witness cited by the AP, police captain Jamil Hussein, doesn't exist and are demanding that the AP "produce" him. Eric Boehlert has a comprehensive rundown on the whole thing here.
So now Eason Jordan, former CNN news chief has invited right wing blogger Michelle Malkin to go to Iraq and see for herself what's going on and, perhaps prove or disprove the AP story. Most commentary I've read takes the position that this is a superb idea. For example:
Jordan is a slick fucker. Malkin is so puffed up with her own bullshit she doesn't understand what he signed her on for.
They're supposed to interview Iraqis who saw six sunnis burned alive. That means leaving the Green Zone. It is really, really dangerous. I mean, there is a great deal of risk involved in this, and these battle tourists are gonna get their bullshit confronted in a real way. When grunts tell them how much they hate Iraqis, the shitty living conditions they deal with. Hell, landing in Baghdad should scare her shitless.
But, Greg Seargent (author of the above summary) at The American Prospect thinks it's a bad idea:
This is very obvious from the writings of Malkin and her cohorts, who have repeatedly insinuated that the AP treasonously in league with terrorists and against America. Curt at Flopping Aces -- a key promoter of the story -- has said that the AP is in "collusion with the enemy," while PowerlineBlog's John Hinderaker has accused the AP of publishing enemy "propaganda." And Malkin herself has defended the U.S. military's right to detain AP photographer Bilal Hussein indefinitely without charging him with anything. This latest assault is more of the same. As a former newsman, do you really want to lend credibility to people who would say such obviously demented things about other journalistic organizations?
While I would normally agree with this position - that doing this is only perpetuating and aiding an intentional distraction - in this case I think it's a good idea. The idea here, intended by the invitation or not, is to let Malkin see this first hand. It's harder to deny if she goes out and gets shot at. If she doesn't go she'll always be able to deny things like the AP story have happened. But once she sees it, she can't deny it. So in this case, a momentary perpetuation of the denial is acceptable for the bigger benefit of disproving this and other denials of how bad the situation is.
No comments:
Post a Comment