Thursday, December 14, 2006

If You Can't Beat 'Em, Outlaw 'Em

A new bill by John McCain to impose very tough requirements on internet sites to "protect" children and copyright holders is getting a lot of attention in the blogosphere. The worry about the bill (which will make site operators legally responsible for what other people say on their site and force site operators to delete any sort of profile of people that are convicted sex criminals) is that it will effectively shut down the blogoshpere.

I disagree. Certainly it won't be a good thing but the internet is way smarter than John McCain and can easily come up with lots and lots of alternatives. First, comments and profiles for everyone will be closed. Yeah, it will suck, but it won't actually DO much. Second, I imagine lots of work arounds like off-shore hosting will be available to continue as before.

It's a cheap stunt and a difficult one to vote against, but hopefully a Democraticly controlled Congress will simply let the bill die a quiet death without a vote.

No comments:

Who links to me?