Monday, December 11, 2006

We Were Soldiers Once...And Are Again

There are very few reporters who simply Know What They're Talking About. When it comes to war reporting, Joe Galloway is one of them. Many reporters in both Vietnam and Iraq have were able to see war up close and thus report with a first hand understanding of what happens in battle. Joe Galloway is different though.

If you don't know who he is, he is the co-author with Lt. Gen. Harold Moore, Ret. of one of the best military histories written, We Were Soldiers Once...And Young. (Later made into the movie We Were Soldiers with Galloway played by Barry Pepper.)

The story told in We Were Soldiers... is that of the Battle of the Ia Drang Valley, the first true battle of the Vietnam War. In late 1965 450 men of the 7th Cavalry (made famous by Custer but now ferried by helicopers not horses) led by then Lt. Col. Hal Moore dropped into the Ia Drang to pick a fight. What they didn't realize was that the area they landed was surrounded by approximately 2,000 North Vietnamese. What followed was several days of intense fighting with the American forces surrounded, cut off and vastly outnumbered.

It was into this situation that Joe Galloway flew on the second day of the battle. He hitched a ride on a supply helicopter and saw battle first hand. At one point he was handed a rifle to defend himself, the situation was so dire. At the end of the battle, Galloway told Moore that he didn't know what to say or how to say it. He found his voice and went on to cover wars around the world. Retired now, he only writes columns and has a new one on leaving Iraq. Like EF Hutton, when Joe Galloway speaks about war, you listen.

Extended clip from E&P:

All the politicians paid the customary lip service in praising the troops and commending them for the terrible sacrifices they must continue to endure while the wrangling and dithering over a futile war goes on with no end in sight.

How can they look at themselves in the mirror every morning?

Some even suggest sending additional U.S. forces to Iraq -- 20,000 to 30,000 more to try to clean up Baghdad, or as Sen. John McCain suggests, 100,000 more to achieve a victory of some kind.

What are they thinking?

The time to use overwhelming force, according to the Caspar Weinberger-Colin Powell doctrine, is when you launch an invasion. Ratcheting up later is just so 1965, and so hopeless a gesture when the situation has already gone to hell.

Let's get a few more things straight right now.

There's no victory waiting for President Bush in Iraq, and nothing that his father's friends say or do can save him from an ignominious end to his presidency in two years and two months, or from the judgment of history.

There will be no convenient and successful negotiation of a "decent interval" with our enemies Iran and Syria to cover our withdrawal from a war that we should never have started.

There can be no successful Vietnamization in Iraq -- standing up more and better Iraqi army and police units and handing control over to them -- when all we're doing is arming and training more recruits for the civil war that clogs the streets of Baghdad with the corpses of the victims of a Sunni-Shia bloodbath.

What we need to do is what none of the commissions and their reports dared to suggest: Begin withdrawing American forces from Iraq right now. Not in 2008. Not after the American death toll has crossed 5,000. Not just in time for a presidential election.

If you worry about the future of Iraq, don't. It will remain what it's always been: a violent, angry land of warring tribes only occasionally beaten and bludgeoned into submission by a homegrown despot like Saddam Hussein.

If you worry about added turmoil and instability in the Middle East, pull some of those departing American forces back to Kuwait and leave them there on standby. Then redirect thought, energy and effort into salvaging Afghanistan, finding Osama bin Laden, saving Lebanon, negotiating peace between Israel and its enemies, rebuilding the U.S. Army and Marine Corps and, oh yes, ending the uncivil war between Republicans and Democrats.

There may be 50 ways to leave your lover, but there's only one way to leave Iraq: Load our people up on their trucks and tank transporters and Bradleys and Humvees and head for the border. Now.

No comments:

Who links to me?