Oprah
A lot of people get upset when a philanthropist does not donate enough or in a way they find personally preferrable. I think that those feelings are generally unfair. Who are you, really, to tell someone where and how to engage in philanthropy.
This, however, is just so ridiculous that it borders on completely indefensible. This describes a new girls' school built (and presumably endowed) in South Africa by Oprah Winfrey.
And now, in 2007, the most exclusive spot on the continent will undoubtedly be in the town of Henly-on-Klip, about 40 miles outside Johannesburg. Set on 22 lush acres and spread over 28 buildings, the complex features oversize rooms done in tasteful beiges and browns with splashes of color, 200-thread-count sheets, a yoga studio, a beauty salon, indoor and outdoor theaters, hundreds of pieces of original tribal art and sidewalks speckled with colorful tiles.
....
Winfrey has spent five years and $40 million building the school
Let me first say that I find this incredibly admirable, particularly the strategy - to build a leadership school for girls with the goal of having them then go out and build the next generation of social, political, economic and community institutions.
However, speding $40 million dollars (not to mention taking 5 years!!) to build a school for only 152 students is a terrible waste of money. While I understand why she might include so many perqs, I believe it is being spent on the wrong things. If your goal is to provide upward mobility to girls and women in a poverty stricken continent, shouldn't using the money to educate as many girls as possible? As it is, she has spent roughly $263,000 per student to build the school (the article is unclear whether the $40 million includes an endowment of fund for operating expenses).
I have no idea what a cost per student could be but let's just use $50,000 (which still seems high). That would mean the school could admit 800 girls.
I get why Oprah is doing it this way. She wants to give these girls everything she can to make their lives better. But what they really need is education, opportunities and support. Not yoga or nice sheets.
No comments:
Post a Comment