Saturday, December 09, 2006

mytube.com

Wow this article from today's WSJ has a bunch of comment worthy stuff.

First, here's the lede of the story:

Four major media companies, including News Corp.'s Fox, Viacom Inc., CBS Corp. and General Electric Co.'s NBC Universal, are in talks about creating a video Web site to compete with Google Inc.'s YouTube, according to people close to the situation.


That's one of those things that sounds smart for about five minutes until the adults think about it. It would be like saying, "VHS has a lock on the video tape market.... Let's come out with our own version and call it Beta!!" Or, "This 'internet' thing sure seems to be hot - let's make our own. We shall call it Prodigy."

When an industry standard pretty much exists (de facto if not officially), you're only going to hurt yourself swimming against the tide, to mix a metaphore. Why? because while some people may really really want to see that clip of the full Survivor confessional and will go to FoxCBSNBCtube.com to get it, most users of youtube.com are going there for the totality of the content. They can watch the clip of The Colbert Report they want to see then watch a music video then watch a couple girls pull each other's hair then watch a fat kid freak out on the roller coaster (my all time favorite).

But with FoxCBSNBCtube.com, you'll only go there for that ONE thing they have that you want. Then you'll go away. There will be very little crossover into other clips based on your previous viewing history or whatever. Call it the craigslist rule: if you build it first, no one will ever be able to build it again.

That plan is also interesting for another reason - isn't that really really close to antitrust violations? The goal here, quite clearly, is to lock out a competitor by withholding content. That's legal - it *is* your content - but to band together is a different story. I'm sure that lots of smart lawyers conferred first and determined these discussions were ok, but if this new collaborative company ever launches, youtube.com will sue immediately and if one sigle analyst wrote a single note in a single page of a single notebook that contained one of a handful of "bad" words and phrases - like "use market share" - there will be a lot of trouble.

But mostly, this is just stupid because it's going against what the internet naturally does - it's putting up barriers where the internet is trying to tear them down.

Next post with less serious takes on the article....

No comments:

Who links to me?