Proprietary Inventory
A few days ago, I wrote about the youtube.com vs. entertainment copyright holders issues, specifically the news that some companies are considering banding together to form their own youtube-clone.
This is a common tactic in industries that have captive or proprietary inventory. Businesses that have proprietary inventory - like entertainment companies - are loathe to allow ANYONE to profit off the distribution of inventory.
To explain by example: I've had some experience in a related industry, movie theaters. If you've seen Seinfeld or have lived in a city that had it, you know what 777-FILM is, a way to buy movie tickets over the phone. In the late 90s, there were lots of ideas about alternate movie ticket distribution models. These were primarily start-ups or point-of-service software vendors, NOT movie theater operators. What these companies wanted to do was to design and rollout electronic movie ticketing distribution including internet purchasing. They would make money by charging a small fee - around $0.25 - on top of the ticket price. Kinda like Ticketmaster but not as expensive.
This was a great idea for a number of reasons. Primarily, because people demanded it. 777-FILM was enormously popular. But also because it provides, even if for a short time, a competitive advantage. Theaters utilizing these alternate distribution methods offer their customers more ways to purchase tickets and a universal service prevents customer confusion. And at that time, these theater chains really needed any help they could get.
To all these entrepreneurs' surprise, the movie theater operators were adamantly opposed and refused to go along with it. Why? Well, because all movie theaters sell that people want is movie tickets. Sure, they sell concessions but only if they sell tickets first. Tickets to movies in any particular theater are captive inventory - only that theater has them and if you want to buy the tickets, you have to buy from that theater on their terms. The theater operator has a monopoly on those specific tickets. Captive inventory
Where it gets kind of screwy is that the theater operators view any profit from those tickets as rightfully theirs since they control it 100%. No one else can sell those tickets without the theater letting them and given that, the theater operators figure they can just do it themselves. The disconnect is that they refused to acknowledge that if they signed a deal with these electronic ticketing companies they would both benefit short- and long-term.
So what happened? The theater operators said no and then went bankrupt (though one didn't necessarily cause the other it is weird that in difficult times, theater operators still refusted). Most of the electronic ticketing companies moved on to other things or went out of business as well. Eventually, theater operators banded together and built fandango.com which they owned themselves. But, for a number of years, they gave up the extra revenue and customer satisfaction that electronic ticketing offered just to maintain total and complete control of their proprietary inventory. And even with fandango.com, they've created a fragmented electronic ticketing market which is bad for everybody. Not every theater operator is part of fandango, some have their own electronic ticketing system and customers can't do one stop shopping. The competition isn't for best or cheapest ticketing systems but rather between theater operators which really isn't much different than things were before.
The overall outcome was bad for everyone and it was all, frankly, petty. Sort of like a kid's "it's mine and I'm not gonna share" attitude.
This is why Fox, NBC and CBS are talking about joining together to create a proprietary youtube-like service. They don't want to share any potential profits from their inventory with anyone else. ABC doesn't even want to share with other entertainment companies in this joint effort. In other words, they're potentially opting to give up revenues, choosing to make it more difficult for customers to find their inventory and incurring the additional investment costs to build and market the new service when youtube has already done that.
You can see this same story repeated everywhere: Napster, iTunes, Tivo, proprietary DVD rental deals, downloading movies, aggregation of newspaper classified ads, plane ticketing and others.
(A good question to ask, especially given the movie ticket example I've cited, is, Hey, concert venues have captive inventory which they allow Ticketmaster to sell so isn't that a problem with your argument? The answer is yes and no. Ticketmaster is itself a monopoly with all the power that monopolies have. Since they already control the distribution chain for concert tickets and have forever, it's harder for venues to do anything about it. Also, Ticketmaster has long-term contracts and when those contracts come up for renewal they are VERY aggressive. And, to be fair, theater operators were probably a little bit worried about getting "Ticketmaster'd" if they let someone else into their distribution chain.)
No comments:
Post a Comment