And What Was She Wearing on the Evening in Question?
No one ever wanted to believe that the Duke lacrosse players Read Seligmann, Colin Finnerty and David Evans raped a stripper hired to perform at a team party. They are white, middle to upper class, good looking, athletes attending a premier college. She is a stripper, a hooker and is black. I really have no idea whether the accused in the Duke case are guilty or innocent. Certainly the publicly available evidence suggests that they may be innocent or guilty of something less than rape. (But that is just what we know primarily from the defense lawyers. I would like to assume that a prosecutor, particularly one with such a long career as DA Mike Nifong, would have stronger evidence than what has been made public before he charged anyone with a crime. But maybe I am naive.)
Back to the point: last spring, Nifong announced the indictments of Seligmann, Finnerty and Evans for first-degree sexual offense, first-degree forcible rape and first-degree kidnapping. Duke University suspended Seligmann and Finnerty (Evans was a senior and apparently allowed to graduate).
DURHAM, North Carolina (CNN) -- Duke University has suspended two of its lacrosse players who were arrested Tuesday on rape and kidnapping charges, a source familiar with the investigation said Wednesday.
The suspension is effective until the case is resolved, the source said.
....
"Historically, it has been the university's practice to issue an interim suspension when a student is charged with a felony or when the student's presence on the campus may create an unsafe situation."
According to a Web site that Duke set up to address questions about the case, when a student faces serious criminal charges, the university can wait, usually at a student's request, to implement its disciplinary process until the case is resolved through the court system. The site adds, "In such an instance, interim actions may be taken."
So apparently Duke's policy regarding students facing criminal charges is to suspend them pending the resolution of criminal charges. And according to CNN's sources - which can only be Duke officials - Seligmann and Finnerty would remain suspended until the "case is resolved."
Seems pretty clear. Charged with a felony = suspension; acquittal or dropped charges = readmission.
Then right before Christmas, Nifong dropped the rape charges against the three. Cable news was full of talking heads condemming Nifong for having brought the charges in the first place (never mind that he did not drop the charges because he decided his case was weak, rather he dropped them because the accuser changed her testimony). What seemed to get largely overlooked in the reporting I saw and read was that the three were still being charged with felonies.
December 22,2006 | DURHAM, N.C. -- Prosecutors dropped rape charges Friday against three Duke University lacrosse players accused of attacking a stripper at a team party, but the three still face kidnapping and sexual offense charges.
Kidnapping and sexual offense charges sound very serious. The kind of serious felony charges that Duke has a policy of suspending pending the outcome of the case. And when the two were suspended, Duke officials said that the suspension was effective until the case is resolved.
Yet despite this case being far from resolved, the university has invited Seligmann and Finnerty to come back to school.
(01/03/07 -- DURHAM) - Suspended Duke University lacrosse players Colin Finnerty and Reade Seligmann have been invited to return to the school as students, more than a week after the Durham district attorney dropped rape charges against them and David Evans and a full semester after the pair were placed on administrative leave pending the outcome of the rape and kidnapping charges against them.
It sure sounds like Duke is acting directly in contradiction to their policies and stated posiitons. My opinion is that the two men should not have been suspended (but hopefully could have been convinced to voluntarily withdraw for a semester or two). But since the university chose to suspend them, they should have the integrity to stick with it. The message they are conveying is that if you commit a crime but hire PR savvy defense attorneys you can avoid official sanctions.
I wonder what the next Duke rape victim will do when choosing whether or not to go to the police or university?
No comments:
Post a Comment