Wednesday, January 10, 2007

Urgin' for No Surgin'

Kargo X over at Daily Kos has a piece up today about the two conflicting anti-escalation bills in the Senate right now.

The first bill, and the one with the most support, is a "Sense of the Senate" resolution. A big ol' heap of "this is what we think." It is non-binding. It is being championed by Senator (and soon to be failed presidential candidate) Joe Biden (D-MD). It also reportedly has the support of at least 10 GOP Senators. The Democrats' goal here is to force those other 39 GOP Senators to go on the record as officially supporting escalation. Kargo X quotes this NYT article:

Democratic leaders said Tuesday that they intended to hold symbolic votes in the House and Senate on President Bush’s plan to send more troops to Baghdad, forcing Republicans to take a stand on the proposal and seeking to isolate the president politically over his handling of the war.


Sounds very wishy-washy, right?

The second bill up for consideration - but only in the sense that it has been announced, it is not actually being considered yet - is one being offered by Senator Ted Kennedy (D-MA). Senator Kennedy is introducing a bill to cut off funding for any escalation:

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,

Section 1. Prohibition on use of funds for escalation of United States forces in Iraq.

Notwithstanding any other provision of law, no Federal funds may be obligated or expended by the United States Government to increase the number of United States forces in Iraq above the level for such forces which existed as of January 1, 2007, without a specific authorization of Congress by law for such an increase.


So far, there has been some disappointment with the Senate Democrats for pushing for the Sense of the Senate bill and not the flat out escalation-rejection proposed by Sen. Kennedy. And it is wishy washy. It is very similar to other gunshy moments in recent years by Democrats. Kargo X:

By scheduling the symbolic vote first -- something I would understand as methodical and calculating under almost any other circumstances -- the substance of the issue is changed. It's no longer a "confrontation" with the White House over Iraq. It's a shadowing. And I think we owe everyone a bit more than that.


(To be fair, Kargo X's argument here seems to be that after the Sense of the Senate resolution, the momentum and urgency will dissapate, the vote will not come up for several more weeks, the the troops will be there and then cutting off funding is cutting off funding for troops on the ground, aka, Not Supporting The Troops. Kargo X always seems to have a pretty good idea about the inner workings of Congress, so his opinion here does carry some weight.)

I do not agree in this case. Perhaps I am naive and perhaps I do not understand the inner workings of the Senate well enough. There are 10 GOP senators willing to vote yes on a Sense of the Senate resolution. If Harry Reid can get them to do so, and the very next day Senatore Kennedy's bill comes up for a vote, those 10 cannot suddenly say, "No no no no, I want escalation." They are stuck with the position, right? And if Harry Reid can get the 49 Democrats and one Independent to vote for the Sense of the Senate resolution (no faith in Connecticut for Lieberman Senator Joe Lieberman on this one), they will be similarly locked in and there will be 60 votes. Enough to override a veto.

As for the concern by Kargo X above, it seems to me that certain people will not let the momentum die - Senator Kennedy and Congressman Murtha being two.

This feels like baby steps. Too many people are still afraid of the boogeyman and need to be cajoled and maybe eventually dragged kicking and screaming.

(HT to TPMCafe, Kargo X and TPM.)

No comments:

Who links to me?