Monday, January 08, 2007

Media - Another WTF Moment

This is the dumbest and most dangerous article I have seen in a long, long time. In fact, I cannot remember ever thinking of a news story, “This article is going to hurt innocent people.”

Do not get me wrong – I do not believe that the press should be censored or censor itself. Nor do I think that they should not report on something because it is a delicate or dangerous topic. But I do think that journalists need to be responsible and compare the news value to the potential negative outcomes. And if the article is treading into dangerous areas and has little or no real news value, journalists should lean towards not reporting on it.

Study: Tween girls at risk for fatness

WASHINGTON - As if being a tween is not hard enough, scientists now call the years between 9 and 12 a time when girls are especially at risk of getting fat.

Girls are more likely to become overweight in those preteen years than when they are teenagers, researchers report Monday in The Journal of Pediatrics.

....

But it did highlight consequences of that adolescent weight gain. Chubby tweens already were seeing their blood pressure and cholesterol levels inch up, backing up earlier research that fat's toll on the arteries begins early. Also, being overweight in childhood brought more than a tenfold risk of a youngster's growing into a fat adult.


I realize that childhood obesity is a serious problem. In fact, it is more than just a problem, it is an epidemic.

But there are other weight-related epidemics young women and girls suffer from: anorexia, bulimia and low self-esteem. Young women are bombarded with body image ideals that are totally unreasonable for most of them. They come to be terrified of weight gain and seek any method of preventing it. This should not be news to anyone.

So how on earth an editor could choose as a headline, “Tween girls at risk for fatness,” is beyond me. To young women I imagine that translates into “You’d better start dieting at 8 otherwise you’ll be fat for life.” Which is a terrible, terrible message.

I conceed there is some news value in this article. Which is why it was published first in The Journal of Pediatrics. It is the kind of thing doctors should know and communicate to parents when discussing childhood nutrition. But for the broader public, the news value is really very low. I would say the only value of this is the “wow” value. The “wow” value is really high, I think, which is probably why the AP reported it.

But what they did not consider, I imagine, is that teens are very savvy – much savvier than most adults give them credit for – and many girls will find this article and send it around to their friends. And they will not get the point of the article – smart nutrition beginning at an early age leads to healthier lives – and instead get the message that they will get fat if they do not take steps during their tween years. Steps which will increase the chances of future eating disorders because behavior learned at an early age is very difficult to change later.

No comments:

Who links to me?