Wednesday, January 10, 2007

iPhone vs iPhone

Yesterday, several of the articles discussing Apple's new iPhone noted that Cisco owned the trademark for the name.

Today, Cisco has sued Apple for trademark infringement. Turns out that not only do they own the trademark, they began using it three weeks ago for a new VoIP phone they are now marketing.

First, I must note that this really is humorous. Apple has a long history of heavy handed legal tactics and deserves every bit of pain this causes. And if Cisco wants, they can cause a lot of pain here and force Apple to change the name midstream (assuming that Cisco wins in court and I am sure they will be at least able to get a TRO fairly quickly).

Second, there's something rotten in Denmark. Apple has been negotiating with Cisco for the use of the name:

"Cisco entered into negotiations with Apple in good faith after Apple repeatedly asked permission to use Cisco's iPhone name," said Mark Chandler, Cisco senior vice president and general counsel, in a statement. "There is no doubt that Apple's new phone is very exciting, but they should not be using our trademark without our permission."


There is absolutely no chance that Cisco just coincidentally introduced their phone three weeks before MacWorld. The phone must have been in development for years and a launch date picked months ago. And something tells me that they would not voluntarily pick the week before Christmas as the launch date. A more likely time and venue, for instance, might be the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas. Which just happens to be going on right now, at the same time as MacWorld where they could assume in advance that the Apple product would be announced.

Here is what I think happened: Apple found out months if not years ago that Cisco (or the predecessor company) owned the trademark. Months ago, Apple approached Cisco and asked to negotiate for the right to use the name, essentially laying their cards on the table. Cisco agreed to negotiate - the name really is not worth very much to them. But in order to get top dollar for the name, they applied it to a new phone they were developing and then rushed to release it before MacWorld so that they could claim the name was in use prior to Apple announcing the iPhone.

On the surface that sounds like smart business. Cisco was just trying to get as much money as they could. But while I do not feel an ounce of sympathy for Apple, they are a victim here. By releasing their phone, Cisco was effectively negotiating in bad faith. Why? In order for Apple to even enter into discussions, they had to admit they were planning to release a cell phone product. And, armed with that knowledge, Cisco decided not to negotiate a licensing agreement but instead put the name to use in order to put Apple in a really bad, expensive position.

It is bad faith because you cannot negotiate with someone if they use the very knowledge of the negotiations to improve their negotiating position. And it is really bad faith to intentionally lure the other side into legal trouble to further increase your leverage. Think of it like this: assume that you own your house and that you run into financial problems. You go to your bank and say, "I either can't pay my mortgage or I can't pay my electric bill. Is there anyway we can come to an agreement that I can miss my payment this month so I don't get my electricity cut off?" And the bank says, "Sure, let's talk about it." While you are talking, the bill comes due and you do not pay it. Then the bank up and forecloses on your house. You never would have not paid the bill if you thought the bank would do that. But they told you they would negotiate.

This is not the same as learning that Apple wanted the name and then going out and seeing who else might want it and what they are willing to pay. This is Cisco knowing Apple wants it and intentionally putting Apple in a really bad spot so they will have to pay more. And not just pay more, but pay whatever Cisco wants. Cisco is not selling the trademark now, they are selling Apple an out on legal problems Cisco created and selling Apple a right to actually launch their product. Those are not things that Cisco "owns" nor are they things that Apple should have to "buy."

Anyway, I think the iPhone (Apple version) is awesome and wish I could afford one.

No comments:

Who links to me?