Wednesday, January 10, 2007

I Support the Troops

I have to say something: I hate, hate the phrase "I/We support the troops." On the most basic level, what you say matters a lot less than what you do. And turning I Support the Troops into a holy phrase has made it possible for peole to utter it, be taken seriously and not do anything to back it up. And WTF does "support" even mean?? The answer is, anything you want it to. Troops is such a broad term as well that it has very little meaning.

Most importantly, however, is that implicit in the phrase is the idea that there are people out there that do not "support" the troops. But who the hell are those people? Sure, I am sure if you dug around enough you could find someone willing to go on the record as wishing the folks in the military harm, but I bet I could find a lot more people willing to go on the record saying that they have been abducted by aliens.

No one seriously does not "support" the troops by any definition. And I doubt anyone ever has. Even for the war protesters in the 60s the issue was the war and any anger there was towards returning soldiers and marines (and there is a lot of evidence that said anger is mostly a myth), it was anger about the war in Vietnam expressed towards the only available domestic symbols.

I respect and thank the members of the military for their service. I think their chosen profession - even if they are not lifers - is noble. I pray for their safety and swift return. And I assume that everyone else in this country agrees with me. So let us respect each other enough to assume that is true of everyone. Let us stop arguing about who supports whom more.

No comments:

Who links to me?