Sunday, January 07, 2007

So, You Want a Divorce, Huh?

This is incredibly stupid. Focus on the Family plans to lobby the Virginia legislature to change the state's laws on divorce. Currently, Virginia is a "no fault" state which pretty much means that if one of the two in a marriage wants to get divorced for any reason, it happens. The sticky stuff is the division of assets and custody, but - at least for asset division - one spouses behavior cannot help or hurt them. In other words if you cheated on your wife and she tries to divorce you, she will not get more money due to the cheating.

Back to Virginia. Focus on the Family wants to get the law changed so that couples with children can only get divorced by mutual consent (except in the case of domestic violence or "cruelty"):

The foundation is advocating "mutual consent divorce" for couples with children, which would require a husband and wife to agree to divorce before a marriage can be legally terminated, except in certain instances, such as abuse or cruelty. The proposed legislation would not affect childless couples.

"Right now, one spouse can unilaterally end [the marriage], and not only is their spouse unable to stop the divorce, their abandonment does not preclude them from having custody of their child," said Victoria Cobb, president of the Family Foundation. "When we send a message that one can up and leave their family and have no consequence, the Old Dominion is encouraging divorce."


This is stupid for a variety of reasons starting with the most basic, stay the eff out of my f'ing marriage. Also, I guess, is that this is a stepping stone to mutual consent divorces for childless couples too, followed by divorce only in the case of X,Y or Z. In otherwords, you cannot get divorced.

But why I think this is really stupid is due to the almost certain unintended consequences (or perhaps intentional, as a neat little bug in the system that will make it even harder to divorce than it seems on the surface). This law, if enacted, would give one party complete control over the other.

Say a married man meets a new woman and wants to divorce his wife to be with the new woman. Wife says, "No...unless I get the house, sole custody, and $X,XXX in monthly alimony."

Or, say this poor wife wanted a divorce:

Contract of Wifely Expectations

....

You will shave every third day which includes chest, legs and pubic area (navel to anus), all areas are to be completely shaven. Above your vaginal slit you may have a patch of pubic hair in any shape that must be centered above your vaginal slit, it will measure no greater than 2.0"x1.0", and will maintain a hair length of less than 1/3".

....

You will wear only thigh highs and garters and thong underwear

....

When we are at home, and alone as a family, you will be naked within 20 minutes of the kids being in bed, and then sleep naked unless instructed otherwise.... When we are not at home or alone as a family ... you will sleep naked. I will make exceptions but only if you do not ask for them.

....

Fellatio must be at least 5 min and may include climax. Intercourse includes anal and vaginal intercourse.... All applications of lube to myself, you or any object will be done by you. [She also gets "good behavior days" for unexpected anal intercourse and other above-and-beyond sex acts.]



Is it even remotely likely that her husband would agree to a divorce without horrendous conditions? This guy would make her life even more miserable before she got his consent on a divorce, consent which I doubt would ever come.

In effect, this makes the party interested in divorce have to be willing to give up everything to get out of the marriage. And the more I think about it, it is not an unintended consequence. It is precisely the point.

And who will this hurt the most? Women in abusive (if only mentally/emotionally abusive) relationships. They will be stuck in the marriage or forced to give up their kids, any alimony, the house, whatever.

Note: I believe that the wife above did get a divorce and got the husband charged with kidnapping and child pornography. But that was after years of marriage. Very sad.

(HT to Americablog.)

No comments:

Who links to me?