Do You Have This in Small?
The story is sad and I believe the motivations are pure, but this is not right:
CHICAGO - In a case fraught with ethical questions, the parents of a severely mentally and physically disabled child have stunted her growth to keep their little "pillow angel" a manageable and more portable size.
The bedridden 9-year-old girl had her uterus and breast tissue removed at a Seattle hospital and received large doses of hormones to halt her growth. She is now 4-foot-5; her parents say she would otherwise probably reach a normal 5-foot-6.
Her parent's side of the story:
"Ashley's smaller and lighter size makes it more possible to include her in the typical family life and activities that provide her with needed comfort, closeness, security and love: meal time, car trips, touch, snuggles, etc.," her parents wrote.
Also, Ashley's parents say keeping her small will reduce the risk of bedsores and other conditions that can afflict bedridden patients. In addition, they say preventing her from going through puberty means she won't experience the discomfort of periods or grow breasts that might develop breast cancer, which runs in the family.
"Even though caring for Ashley involves hard and continual work, she is a blessing and not a burden," her parents say. Still, they write, "Unless you are living the experience ... you have no clue what it is like to be the bedridden child or their caregivers."
Her doctor's:
Dr. Douglas Diekema, an ethicist at Children's Hospital and Regional Medical Center in Seattle, where Ashley was treated, said he met with the parents and became convinced they were motivated by love and the girl's best interests.
Diekema said he was mainly concerned with making sure the little girl would actually benefit and not suffer any harm from the treatment. She did not, and is doing well, he said.
"The more her parents can be touching her and caring for her ... and involving her in family activities, the better for her," he said. "The parents' argument was, `If she's smaller and lighter, we will be able to do that for a longer period of time.'"
My opinion is that despite what the parents and doctors are saying, this really isabout them, not her. Here is her parents' longer explanation from their website:
Unlike what most people thought, the decision to pursue the “Ashley Treatment” was not a difficult one. Ashley will be a lot more physically comfortable free of menstrual cramps, free of the discomfort associated with large and fully-developed breasts, and with a smaller, lighter body that is better suited to constant lying down and is easier to be moved around.
Ashley’s smaller and lighter size makes it more possible to include her in the typical family life and activities that provide her with needed comfort, closeness, security and love: meal time, car trips, touch, snuggles, etc. Typically, when awake, babies are in the same room as other family members, the sights and sounds of family life engaging the baby’s attention, entertaining the baby. Likewise, Ashley has all of a baby’s needs, including being entertained and engaged, and she calms at the sounds of family voices. Furthermore, given Ashley’s mental age a nine and a half year old body is more appropriate and more dignified than a fully grown female body.
What take away from this statement is that menstrual cramps and the weight of breasts are intolerable according to her parents. I am a dude so maybe I am being naive and ignorant, but billions of women deal with both every day and surgery is only ever considered in the absolute extreme cases. I suspect the parents do not want to add menstration to the list of Ashley's needs.
In the pictures on the parents' website, it appears that Ashley has a wheel chaire that gets her around. Presumably they come in adult sizes. I recognize just how difficult it must be caring for a 60lb sack of potatoes (from a lifting stand point) and 120lbs of dead weight is clearly more difficult. But from what I am reading here, she is able to participate in family activities and be with the family even in an adult size. It will just be more difficult to get her there.
I think the most unpleasant thing I have read, however, is her parents' explanation that the body will better fit the mind now and that that is somehow a justification. No, that is cosmetic and that is alllll about you.
I do not doubt at all that her parents love her. The pictures on their website are of a very lovely family - and it seems, a wealthy one which is good. And Ashley herself is really f'ing cute:
Anyway, this surgery is done but I hope it does not become a common procedure, nor any similar procedure to make the disabled "easier to deal with." I wish the "Ashley family" well.
No comments:
Post a Comment