Hey Grandpa, STFU
Investment banks are not kind institutions. But they are 100% predictable: they will do anything, anything up to and including breaking the law, to make money.
Which is how I know that this lawsuit has no basis:
NEW YORK (Reuters) - A former Morgan Stanley managing director has filed a federal lawsuit accusing the Wall Street bank of firing him because he was too old.
Edward Sullivan, who worked in Morgan Stanley's retail operations, accused two human resources executives of substituting a "made-up, poison-pen critique" of his performance for legitimate evaluations.
He said they did so to create a paper trail that ultimately led to his firing last May 13, 10 days before his 56th birthday.
The Connecticut resident said he had worked for Morgan Stanley for more than 24 years, rising to managing director in 1999, and had been paid as much as $1 million a year.
Sullivan filed his lawsuit this week against Morgan Stanley and the executives in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.
He is asking for his job back with seniority and benefits, and at least $30 million of actual and punitive damages.
A Morgan Stanley spokeswoman declined immediate comment.
Wall Street banks regularly face discrimination lawsuits. In 2004, Morgan Stanley agreed to pay $54 million to settle bias charges filed on behalf of hundreds of women.
"Retail operations" is pretty vague, but probably means he works in the old Dean Witter brokerage business. His job was probably to manage a team of stock brokers in addition to having some clients of his own. More broadly, however, his job was to make money for Morgan Stanley. If he did that, I can guarantee Morgan Stanley could have given a sh!t about how old he was. If he was not making them money, they would have given him a chance and then canned him. It is a tough business, but that is the reason they get paid so well - investement bankers' jobs are very unsecure.
Another issue to note in this situation is the fact that Mr. Sullivan worked for Morgan Stanley for 24 years and it took him 17 to make managing director (according to this press release, however, Mr. Sullivan was not promoted to MD until the end of 2002 which would mean that it took him 20 years.)
That is an extraordinarily long time to make MD. I am not too familiar with retail brokerage, but investment bankers can expect to make MD in around nine or 10 years. Maybe 12. Something is very very strange with a banker who takes 20 years. In fact, I am surprised he was even allowed to stay that long without promotion.
The last issue which casts doubt on Mr. Sullivan's claims is his argument that HR changed his performance reviews. Again, I am not too familiar with how it works in retail operations, but generally at review time, investment bankers electronically submit a list of people - both senior and junior to them - that they worked with in the past year. Then all of those people must submit reviews for the banker in question. Similarly he or she will review all those they submitted as co-workers. The reviews are submitted electronically. Then a committee of superiors reviews all the reviews and comes up with a composite review. There is not an opportunity for editing and/or submitting false reviews.
For junior employees, their compensation and continued employment is dependent wholely on these reviews. But for senior bankers, "revenue generators," their compensation and continued employment is base almost wholely on how much money they made for the bank in the previous year.
I doubt Mr. Sullivan was fired for being old (there are plenty of old people running around investment banks - in fact most MDs are his age). He was almost certainly fired for not brining in any revenue.
No comments:
Post a Comment